Bioidentical Hormones or Drugs for Menopause Symptoms?

Menopause Choices Got You Jumping Through Hoops?

Menopause Choices Got You Jumping Through Hoops?

A friend of mine was complaining recently about the trouble with taking post-menopausal bioidentical hormones, such as estrogen, progesterone, and testosterone. You have to apply them.

Turns out the nightly application of drops and creams in measured doses was driving her crazy. “Why,” she moaned, “Do I have go through all this?”

“Uh, because you feel better,” I reminded her for the umpteenth time. “And you’re probably more likely to avoid a range of diseases thanks to the many protective effects of estrogen.”

“Oh yeah,” she said. “I forgot.”

That’s menopause for you. Easy to forgot the symptoms when you don’t have them anymore. But what do you do if you’re still suffering through it?

Women have had two obvious choices when it comes to menopause relief: grin and bear it, or replace the estrogen you’ve lost through menopause, addressing a range symptoms in one just one hormone (the estrogen).

Ah, but now there’s a third option, thanks to the drug companies. If you don’t want to take estrogen and you don’t want to suffer either, your docs probably got a drug or twenty up her sleeve that can help. Yup, there’s a drug for pretty much every menopause symptom a woman can experience, including anxiety, moodiness, depression, insomnia, loss of libido, hot flashes, and vaginal dryness. There’s also a drug to treat most of the diseases we’re more likely to get as a consequence of estrogen loss (osteoporosis, dementia, cardiovascular disease such as high cholesterol and high blood pressure). Everyday, more are on their way.

The drug companies are promoting their multi-drug (polypharmacy) approach to managing menopause by demonizing estrogen. Despite the fact that the science is not on their side, they are arguing the risk of estrogen replacement is far too great as compared to its benefit. Better to take a pill for every problem, they say. Even if that means you’ve got a dozen or so problems and need a dozen or so pills.

That’s how to make money in the drug world. And that’s how to wind up with a tangle of drug-related side effects in a post-menopausal woman’s world.

So what will it be? Ignore the negative, unsubstantiated drug company propaganda based on how evil estrogen is, or make your own decisions based on the science – all of it? I mean, does any woman really care about self-empowerment anymore?

  • Share/Bookmark

Related posts:

1 Star2 Stars3 Stars4 Stars5 Stars (1 votes, average: 5.00 out of 5)
Loading ... Loading ...

permalink

If you enjoyed this post, please leave a comment and subscribe via email or in a feed reader to receive future articles and join the conversation!

Comments

Hi,

Google brought me here as I try to find HRT info. I’ve been trying to make the decision between bioidenticals, hrt, and doing nothing and think I’m leaning in the direction of bioidenticals. Two articles that I found helpful are from the women’s health site womentowomen:

Bioidenticals: are they right for you?

and

Bioidentical hormones — a guide to your options and alternatives

I look forward to following your blog!

Thanks for those. I know this site. I’ve been curious about their program because women are always asking what doctors I’d recommend for hormone help around menopause. Can they really help by phone and email? Have you tried them? Even with all the information you’re finding, do you still have some unanswered questions? I’m always interested in hearing what women are doing. I also like Oprah’s coverage on menopause.

Hi Pamela,

I know someone who really changed her life from Women to Women and that’s how I learned about the place (I’m not a patient — but I realized the clinic is not that far away from where I live in New England. I’m toying with the idea of making a face-to-face appt.). So far, I am digging all the great information there! I really like Marcelle Pick’s views on aging. She needs to be on Oprah!

Keep me posted on how you do. So many of my friends can’t find a doc who will help them with hormones. Between us gals, most docs are in CYA mode, if you know what I mean. They worried about the lawsuits. We worry about the hot flash and everything else menopause can bring…good luck!

What do you think?

(required)

(required)